You Pay Contractors, Not Employees — So Why Could You Still Owe Payroll Tax?
People. Preserve. Protect. Prosper.
Written by: Melissa Cunliffe (CA)
Paying someone as a contractor does not automatically put their payments outside payroll tax.
That often surprises business owners, because we naturally think of payroll tax as a tax on wages paid to employees. But under state payroll tax laws, certain payments to independent contractors can also be treated as taxable wages.

The Uber Australia High Court Decision and Its Payroll Tax Implications
That distinction has become much more important following a High Court decision handed down on 4 November 2026.
Uber Australia lost its challenge to New South Wales payroll tax assessments of about $81.5 million relating to fares it passed on to drivers between 2015 and 2020. The Court found that the agreements were relevant contracts under the NSW legislation and that payments remitted to drivers were connected with the driving services they provided.
The fact that Uber described itself as a payment-collection agent did not decide the issue.
Why Contractor Labels Do Not Automatically Determine Payroll Tax Liability
This does not mean every Australian business that hires a contractor suddenly owes payroll tax.
It also does not decide that those contractors must be employees for every other legal purpose. Different laws ask different questions.
The important lesson is that the substance of a working arrangement matters more than the label used on an invoice.
When Can Contractor Payments Be Treated as Taxable Wages?
Imagine you operate a growing construction business.
You have eight employees and regularly use the same specialist tradesperson, who invoices through their own company. They have an ABN, provide their own tools and describe themselves as independent. That may be entirely correct for their working relationship. But for Victorian payroll tax, you still need to ask whether the agreement is a relevant contract and, if so, whether an exclusion applies.
Understanding Victoria's Relevant Contract Rules
In Victoria, the State Revenue Office explains that contractor payments may be treated as wages where services are supplied under a relevant contract. The rules can apply whether the contractor operates as an individual, company, partnership or trust.
Importantly, the Victorian rules include exclusions for particular circumstances, such as some short-term engagements, services ordinarily provided to the public, particular equipment-based arrangements and qualifying owner-drivers.
For example, a one-off contractor hired to complete an office renovation may be very different from someone providing core services to your business on a continuing basis.
A contractor who serves many unrelated customers may raise a different question from a person who works predominantly for one business. Even then, the exclusions contain conditions and need to be tested carefully; there is no universal rule that having more than one client is enough.
How Payroll Tax Thresholds and Grouping Rules Affect Businesses
Another issue is scale.
Payroll tax generally becomes relevant when a business or group crosses the applicable state wage threshold. An individual business may look small, but grouping rules can bring related entities together.
Payments to contractors can therefore change a group’s position even when ordinary employee wages appear to sit below the threshold.
Payroll Tax Considerations for Businesses Operating Across Multiple States
For businesses operating in more than one state, the answer can become more complicated again.
You need to consider where the services are performed, which state rules apply and how interstate wages affect thresholds. A Victorian business should not assume that all outcomes in the NSW Uber case will apply identically to its contractors.
Reviewing Your Contractor Arrangements and Payroll Tax Exposure
The useful starting point is to understand how people actually work in your business.
Who provides the service?
Is it part of your regular operations?
Who controls the payment process?
How long is the arrangement?
What do the contracts say?
What happens in practice?
It is also worth reviewing historical contractor payments where the arrangements have remained unchanged for years.
Protecting Your Business from Unexpected Payroll Tax Costs
The real risk is discovering an unexpected payroll tax exposure after the business has already spent the money.
A contractor arrangement can be commercially sensible, but it needs to be understood as part of the overall cost of delivering your services. Getting that right protects the margins you rely on today and gives you more confidence when you plan to grow.
Unsure whether your contractor arrangements could create a payroll tax liability? Contact 4P's Future Accounting to discuss your business structure and payroll tax obligations.
Disclaimer
This article does not constitute financial advice and is for general information only. It does not take into account any individual’s personal objectives, situation or needs, and is not intended as professional advice. Any similarity to an individual’s personal circumstances and the examples provided in this article is purely coincidental. Any person acting upon such information without receiving specific advice, does so entirely at their own risk.
Authorisation under an Australian Financial Services Licence (AFSL) is not required in the provision of this article and the author plus Future Accounting Group Pty Ltd is not acting in its capacity as an Australian Financial Services Licence holder
Liability limited by a scheme approved under professional standards legislation.



